Checked both and I'm still having issues...

edit:

I even tried a different method. I created the images and uploaded them independently to my server :

http://www.lasersquadorlando.com/images/aresdown1.jpg
http://www.lasersquadorlando.com/images/aresdown2.jpg
http://www.lasersquadorlando.com/images/aresdown3.jpg

And for instance aresdown3.jpg is already 91x91 and I am getting this message:

Kiel, One Panel could not resize the image. Please try another.

edit again:

So I made the images a little larger so they could be resized but I'm now running into the issue that the last uploaded image is the one being used for all three thumbnails even though I am going through and trying to upload each individual thumbnail for each section. Please advise.